Maplewood Counseling

Navigating the Crossroads: Should You Stay or Go?

Navigating the Crossroads: Should You Stay or Go?

Deciding the future of a relationship is one of life’s most challenging crossroads. You might feel caught in a loop of uncertainty, weighing happy memories against present pain. Questions like, “Can we fix this?” or “Is it time to let go?” can feel overwhelming, leaving you feeling stuck and alone. Whether you’re in a marriage or a committed partnership, this period of questioning is a sign that something needs to change.

Feeling uncertain is a valid and common experience. Perhaps you are grappling with the aftermath of an affair, trying to heal from broken trust. Maybe you feel a deep sense of disconnect, as if you and your partner are living separate lives. These moments of pain and confusion deserve to be met with compassion and clarity. This guide is here to help you explore your feelings in a safe, non-judgmental way, empowering you to find the path that is right for you.

Understanding the Doubts in Your Relationship

When a relationship is in crisis, it’s natural to question everything. The path forward feels foggy, and you might not be sure if you can find your way back to each other.

Does any of this sound familiar?

  • You are struggling to forgive your partner for infidelity or a betrayal of trust.
  • You feel a lingering hurt from times your partner wasn’t there for you when you needed them most.
  • You find it difficult to move past old arguments or painful events that keep resurfacing.
  • There’s a constant feeling that your needs are not being met, or that you’ve been deprioritized for other people or obligations.

These are significant emotional hurdles. They create a heavy burden that can make it hard to feel positive about your partner and your future together. Recognizing these patterns is the first step toward addressing them. The pain you feel is real, and it’s important to acknowledge it without judgment.

The Complex Path of Forgiveness

Forgiveness is often discussed as a key to moving forward, but it’s rarely a simple act. It is a complex, personal journey. Forgiveness does not mean forgetting what happened or condoning the actions that caused you pain. Instead, it is a process of releasing the hold that anger and resentment have on you, primarily for your own well-being.

Can forgiveness save a relationship? Sometimes. When both partners are willing to engage in honest, open, and sometimes difficult conversations, it is possible to heal and rebuild. It requires a shared commitment to understanding each other’s perspectives and working collaboratively to create a new foundation.

However, forgiveness does not always mean reconciliation. You can forgive someone for your own peace of mind and still decide that the healthiest choice is to end the relationship. The goal is to make a decision that honors your well-being, whether that means staying together and healing, or parting ways with mutual respect.

What is Discernment Counseling?

When you’re on the brink of a major relationship decision, Discernment Counseling offers a unique and supportive path. Unlike traditional couples therapy, which is often aimed at fixing the relationship, discernment counseling helps you gain clarity and confidence about the future of your partnership.

This short-term approach is designed for couples where one person is leaning towards ending the relationship while the other wants to save it. The primary goal is not to solve your problems, but to help you decide if your problems can be solved.

Over one to five sessions, a therapist will help you and your partner:

  • Look honestly at your relationship, including what has worked and what hasn’t.
  • Understand each person’s contributions to the current challenges.
  • Explore three potential paths forward: ending the relationship, committing to six months of intensive couples therapy, or maintaining the status quo.

Discernment counseling provides a safe, structured space to slow down and make a thoughtful, deliberate decision, free from pressure. It empowers you to move forward with a clearer understanding of your own needs and the dynamics of your relationship.

Finding Your Way Forward

Feeling stuck in a painful place is exhausting. You don’t have to navigate this uncertainty alone. Seeking professional support can provide you with a safe, confidential space to explore your feelings, understand your options, and find the clarity you need to move forward.

Whether you choose to work on your relationship or decide it’s time to part ways, therapy can help you process your emotions and develop the tools for a healthier future. We are here to support you in exploring your next steps with empathy and guidance. Reaching out is a brave and powerful step toward finding peace and resolution.

Book Your Session

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: How do I know if my relationship is truly over?
A: There is no single sign, but consistent indicators include a lack of emotional or physical intimacy, feeling indifferent rather than angry during conflicts, imagining a future without your partner that brings relief, and feeling that your core values and life goals no longer align. If attempts to communicate and reconnect consistently fail, it may be a sign that the relationship has run its course.

Q: My partner doesn’t want to go to therapy. What can I do?
A: This is a common challenge. You can start by expressing your feelings in a non-blaming way, explaining that you want to go to therapy to improve the relationship for both of you. If they remain resistant, consider individual therapy. Working on yourself can still positively impact the relationship dynamics and provide you with the clarity and support you need to make decisions about the future.

Q: Is it normal to still love someone but know you have to break up?
A: Yes, it is very normal. Love is complex and doesn’t just disappear. You can deeply care for someone while recognizing that the relationship is unhealthy or no longer serving your well-being. Ending a relationship in this context is a difficult but often necessary act of self-compassion.

Q: How can we break up amicably, especially if we have children?
A: An amicable split requires mutual respect and a commitment to open communication. Focus on shared goals, like co-parenting effectively. Agree to communicate respectfully, avoid blaming each other, and set clear boundaries. A therapist or mediator can be incredibly helpful in facilitating these conversations and creating a healthy post-breakup plan.

Q: How long will it take to get over a breakup?
A: There is no set timeline for healing, as it’s a deeply personal process. Allow yourself to grieve the loss of the relationship and the future you envisioned. Factors like the length of the relationship, the circumstances of the breakup, and your support system will influence your healing journey. Be patient and compassionate with yourself.

Get Care Now

Helpful Resources for Couples Seeking Counseling